Skip to main content

THE DUNNING KRUGER-EFFECT

 

 


 

By Jorge Manuel Zelaya Fajardo

www.jorgemanuelzelaya.com

August 21st,2020

 
 

 “Ignorance breeds confidence more often that knowledge.”

-- Charles Darwin

  

 

 

 I must confess that the first time I heard about the Dunning-Kruger effect I felt a bit uncomfortable. An awkwardness stemming from a potential uncovered truth. My first thought was: Am I suffering from the Dunning Kruger effect without knowing it?  Therefore I proceeded to do what I usually do whenever I have a doubt ... I immerse myself in the insatiable and tireless search for knowledge in any possible reliable source. After doing so, a simultaneous calm and unease came to me. The calm was due to the fact that when I read carefully what the effect consisted of, I realized that practically all human beings have it , to a lesser or greater degree. The concern came from finding out what I should do about it now.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a bias whereby human beings, with little skill or knowledge in some subject, suffer from an illusory superiority considering themselves more skillful, capable or intelligent than other people with confirmed greater preparation than themselves. However, perhaps the most serious problem is that the person himself has a manifest inability not to recognize his own incompetence. David Dunning (Ph.D. in psychology from Stanford University and professor at Cornell) and Justin Kruger (Ph.D. in psychology from Cornell University and professor at New York University) formally presented the study results in 1999 with a publication in the renowned Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

  I must confess that my greatest discomfort with the study did  not lay  in the fact that I showed the Dunning-Kruger effect in some activities of my life; but rather that my passion for the concepts of reaching my maximum potential, developing self-esteem and self-confidence, were somewhat questioned by my personal bias. So how do you know if you are as good as you think you are? How do you know where the fine nylon line is between self-esteem and illusory superiority? This made me,in a very healthy way, question my knowledge by submitting myself to a more in-depth study.

 

The truth is that it was not until a couple of years later, that due to the testimony of two professional sports’ legends   that I managed to find the answer, at least partially. Bob Bowman, swimming coach of Olympic champion Michael Phelps and the recently deceased Kobe Bryant, one of the best players in the history of world basketball. Both sports legends could, through a single sentence each and independently, very positively influence my understanding of the Dunning-Kruger effect within the infinite imperfection of my intellect. Bob Bowman redefines the concept of champion as: “Not only the person who beats others in competition by taking the medals, but the one who, even better, beats himself. “ A simply powerful phrase. On the other hand, Kobe Bryant made it clear very well when in an interview with the Wall Street Journal newspaper, already retired from basketball and beginning his career in business, he said: “I don't know if I'm good at business, but I'm going to find out for myself."  A extraordinary mix of determination and courage.

 Both human beings  helped me to  clearly see  the basis of what could be the antidote to the Dunning-Kruger effect: Having that unique  combination of humility and self-esteem to undergo the real test and not the subjective opinion of what oneself believes or wants to believe. The message is very clear: The only way to know if I am that good is to try it out for myself, overcoming my own limitations but obediently submitting myself to the test of seeing the results obtained. Results strip us. The measurable results, audited by third parties and under equal conditions for our competitors, are really a key piece in the process. Definitely the antidote for the Dunning-Kruger effect is a capsule of two parts, which are: a) The results obtained from our performance and b) The objective feedback from everyone that watches our performance.

 The results, being cold and dispassionate, provide me with a report card that should not be rationalized, justified or questioned; but rather studied and analyzed. If I did not get the results, it is a matter of an error in the process or simply that there is something that I do not know how to do or am not doing.

Honest, direct, genuine and timely feedback is impressively effective. It may not be so pleasant to our ears that our affective shield will rush to protect us; however, the goal should be to listen carefully to it.

  

Due to my Reticular Activating System in the brain, just learning what the Dunning-Kruger effect is, made me notice it in political leaders, business leaders, athletes and public figures. Now I see more often people who have manifestations of deep illusory superiority who really think they are more competent than they really are, belittling professionals with much better preparation and more experience.

 Finally, I think that seeing the results and receiving adequate feedback on our actual performance would be halfway there, if we did not seek ACTION. Personally, I think this action is called KAIZEN (continuous improvement in Japanese). Disciplining ourselves to improve, correct, or redirect after seeing results dooms us to reduce the Dunning-Kruger effect.

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

EL DECÁLOGO DE MAVILA

“Un viaje de mil millas debe comenzar con un simple paso” Proverbio Chino.

En mis clases de Gestión de la Calidad en los distintos Programas de Maestría en la Universidad Católica de Honduras, hay un tema que me apasiona particularmente porque tiene que ver directamente con mi país, con la Región Centroamericana y con Latinoamérica entera. Es un tema teórico pero con una aplicación práctica real. Es un tema fácil de entender, pero difícil de aplicar. Es un tema en que todos coincidimos, pero pocos aplicamos. Ese tema es el Decálogo del Desarrollo de Octavio Mavila.

Octavio Mavila, distribuidor de motocicletas japonesas en Perú durante décadas, viajó varias veces al Japón por negocios. Su inquietud por saber cuál era la diferencia principal entre los obreros japoneses y peruanos lo llevó a estudiar con detenimiento cada viaje y descubrir que la clave era la forma como los niños japoneses aprendían progresivamente los valores de la vida. Tal observación lo impulsó a fundar el Instituto del …

DOMINGO DE PASCUA. JESÚS HA RESUCITADO

Por Jorge Manuel Zelaya Fajardo www.jorgemanuelzelaya.com Abril 21, 2019 En lo personal como creyente, me tomó varios años internalizar por completo que la Pascua de la Resurrección es más importante que la Pascua de Navidad. La Pascua de la Resurrección es el centro de la fe cristiana. Representa el triunfo de la vida sobre la muerte, es la manifestación última de la fe en Cristo Jesús. Sin embargo, esta tremenda fiesta de conmemoración de que Jesús venció a la muerte, no puede quedar como una celebración casual o como acontecimiento anual de calendario. Jesús ha resucitado por una razón. La razón de la vida sobre la muerte, es decir, por una razón de esperanza de vida eterna. En lo personal, me parece que una buena manera de “operacionalizar” ( léase aplicar de manera práctica , real, concreta y directa tan magnánimo acontecimiento en nuestra bastante imperfecta y mundana vida diaria) la resurrección de Jesús podría ser de tres maneras: 1) Entender como Jesús llegó a este momento. 2) L…

ESPERANZA EN MEDIO DE CRISIS

Por Jorge Manuel Zelaya Fajardo www.jorgemanuelzelaya.com Marzo 25, 2020

Hola. Mi nombre es Jorge Manuel Zelaya Fajardo y quiero compartir algo con usted. Estas palabrasno buscan ser un estudio epidemiológico del Covid 19. Estas palabras no buscan ser un análisis macroeconómico de la realidad mundial. Estas palabras tampoco buscaran darle una dosis de falsos azúcares motivacionales para negar la realidad. Estas palabras lo único que buscan es que usted aplique, en su vida personal y profesional, cinco (5) acciones prácticas de fácil aplicación y alto impactoque puedan ayudar a aumentar en un% (aunque fuese pequeño) su bienestar en los próximos días o semanas. Cuando la Organización Mundial de la Salud (OMS) declaró el coronavirus (COVID -19) como una pandemia, comencé a sentir que el virus nacido en Wuhan, China a fines del año pasado podía tocar las puertas de mi ciudad en cualquier momento. Y lo hizo. Aquellos que no recuerdan la historia están condenados a repetirla decía George Santa…